Memoirs of a Geisha

This seems to be one of those films which feels flawless, but isn't very good. Flawless in the sense that everything from direction, to cinematography, music, and performances are all good, yet it doesn't all add up. It's about the life of a geisha in WWII era Japan, and the rigorous life and dedication is requires. I honestly can't put my finger on where it is that this movie goes wrong, but I know it does. The luminous Ziyi Zhang plays the titular geisha, and her smile alone could carry a film, as it almost does this one, but not make it great. Of all the actors, however, Gong Li once again proves herself to be probably the world's most formidable actress, and now in two different languages. Her character, and the film itself, at times feel like an indirect sequel to Zhang Yimou's Raise the Red Lantern, also starring Gong. This film, however, is beautiful but lifeless, even though the talented cast desperately want to bring it to life. Rob Marshall is at least a competent director, but not yet good enough to elevate what may only be an average story into a good film.